Comment Friday for February 29th

11 Comments on this post

Trackbacks

1. Beth said:

   I was finally hit with the big 0.I went from a a PR5 to a PR3 initially and stayed there some how while everyone else went to 0. I checked a few sites that I KNOW utilize every paid to service available and unbelievably several are still PR3. It’s as if Google picks who they want and allow spammy blogs to stay put. Personally? I don’t care, because most of the blogosphere now knows how ridiculous Google’s PR is simply due to the fact it doesn’t mean you are banned from their search results. I get a 1000+ uniques a day,(for my blog, which isn’t a niche and is the Seinfeld of the blogging world-a blog about nothing-that’s damn good), most of which coming from Google/MSN/Yahoo-yet the PR is supposed to make my blog more worthy? Ok. Sure.

   February 29th, 2008 at 11:59 am
2. sir jorge said:

   I’m doing comment fridays on my site now too..

   as for pr, my skateboarding blog, which has no paid posts or anything unrelated to skateboarding, got docked from pr 1 to 0 this week. That was going to be my goldmine…now I’m upset.

   February 29th, 2008 at 3:15 pm
3. Don said:

   In Relation to Beths comment; i may self have just recently started my site been about three months i think with small content additions once every few weeks. Traffic wise according to analytics i get between 30-50 uniques a day.
   SEO wise i have just done the basics, readable URL’s, metadata, a sitemap over at google webmasters and generally commenting on different blogs i visit on a regular basis.
   To my surprise i hit PR2 today. In perspective two months a go i was PR 0, After fixing URL’s and metadata i hit PR1 in Jan and now I recently brought my domain name and have done no tweaking think i published 1 article this month and i hot PR2.
   Im not sure how PR actually works but im not complaining.

   February 29th, 2008 at 3:35 pm
4. Tay - Super Blogging said:

   Before the latest update, I was a PR3. I was very exciting for the most recent update because I knew that would increase – WRONG! Google finally caught me for selling dofollow advertisements, etc. and they zapped me down to a PR0. Considering I haven’t corrected my ways and haven’t asked for reinclusion, I guess I’m going to be stuck with it. But if I don’t sell my ads, or make them all nofollow, I’ll hardly make as much money.

   Even if Google does it to make their search results and their algorithm and everything better and more “natural”, sometimes I just hate it.

   February 29th, 2008 at 5:58 pm
5. Beth said:

   Google doesn’t want people making money unless it’s done their way, which means- we’d still make little or no money as non A-list bloggers. We have to remember- Google is not the Internet Police. No where is it written that Google has a right to dictate what we write, what we link to and whether or not we’re compensated for it. I’m going to continue to do things my way. Google doesn’t pay for my hosting or domain renewal charges I do-blogging for compensation is not against the law as Google is making it out to be.

   February 29th, 2008 at 6:04 pm
6. Beth said:

   @Don- When I referred to “spammy blogs” I meant those which are still utilizing every paid to post service available. Your blog is new and you haven’t had time to establish what your content is and how your blog will perform within a given period. Google is slapping blogs that have been around for a while-established, paid and NON paid posts/advertisements, with no rhyme or reason. It baffles me as to why they’re also knocking the PR down on blogs who don’t blog for compensation- I know of a few bloggers who have never had a single advertisement or a paid post on the blog, but they’ve been dropped to PR0. I think John Chow should have been slapped harder, since he makes more than us non A-listers, yet Google only dropped him to a PR3 from a PR4. A year ago I was on track to reach a PR6. I’m not worried. All I’ll do is keep blogging, continue using SEO to get traffic and commenting on blogs. This is more important to me than a page rank.

   February 29th, 2008 at 6:43 pm
7. Julie said:

   PR can bite me, I went from 3 to 0, cause I do paid blogs. Oh well. Congrats on losing the 7 lbs!

   February 29th, 2008 at 7:28 pm
8. ANCA said:

   Hi Matthew! Hi everybody! I’ve just found your site on pushstandards.com. Will be checking back, looks like there’s a lot of useful info (I’m a very new blogger, and need it :)) I’ve just launched a contest on my blog, and want to invite everybody: http://megavegalicious.com/2008/02/27/my-very-first-contest-everyones-invited/ (I’ve seen you’ve also got a category called “contests”)Thanks and, by the way, after I’ll get some help from you, I’ll tell you how my PR goes 😛

   March 1st, 2008 at 5:03 am
9. Matthew Henrickson said:

   thanks for the great comments we only had half the day to leave them 🙂

   I chose Beth as the winner with her great comments! Congrats

   March 1st, 2008 at 10:20 am
10. Katalina said:

    I am totally fed up with Google. Like others have said, they don’t pay my hosting fees and they can’t tell me how to run my blog. Thank goodness there are other valid ways to get traffic other than Google search. Because of do-follow links a a couple of disclosed paid posts, one of my sites went from a PR1 to a PR0. That despite an impressive increase in traffic and backlinks.
    I’ve said a lot more about this on my blog.

    March 1st, 2008 at 2:37 pm
11. KaraCoatta said:

    My blog is pretty new, It’s been up since November and I still have 0 PR. I’m sure its because the layout I chose to use creates a duplicate content issue off the homepage and I dofollow links.

    I need to get my act together and nofollow some areas on my homepage so I remove the duplicate content issue, It’s just one of those things that’s been on my mind I just haven’t had the time to do it… maybe ill do it now 🙂

    March 1st, 2008 at 6:48 pm

LEAVE A COMMENT